You Might Also Like
Mystery Hat
FREE Shipping on U.S. orders over $99
<p>Earn%20[points_amount]%20when%20completing%20this%20purchase.</p>
You don't pick it. We do. That's the whole point.
One hat. Total mystery. Could be a bold print, could be a past-season cult favorite, could be the one that sold out before you could grab it. You won't know until it lands on your doorstep, and that's exactly how we like it.
For the weirdos and underdogs who trust the chaos. No returns, no exchanges, no peeking. Just vibes and a very good hat.
- One randomly selected Burnt Toast hat
- Curated from our archive of bold prints and fan favorites
- Final sale -- the mystery is the magic
<p>Earn%20[points_amount]%20when%20completing%20this%20purchase.</p>
-
Not the perfect fit? You have 14 days to request a return or size exchange.
✔️ Store credit issued (valid 1 year)
✔️ Same-item size exchanges available
✔️ Items must be unworn with tags attachedFinal sale items aren’t eligible.
If we send something wrong or defective, we’ll make it right. Initiate a return or exchange here in our help center. -
Please allow 3–7 business days for your order to process — we’re getting your Burnt Toast goods ready 🔥
Enjoy free standard shipping on orders $99+, or upgrade to 1–3 business day shipping for $14.99.
-
For best results, always wash on cold and turn your garment inside out to protect the design. We highly recommend air drying to preserve the shape and print. If ironing is needed, use low heat only — never high heat directly on the fabric. Do not bleach or use harsh detergents. Handle with care, and your piece will stay looking fresh.
-
Need help with an order? Check out our help center and submit a ticket.